Used Holden Astra: Common Problems and Which Years to Buy
What to check on a used Astra, what a problem looks like, and when to walk away.
Covers
- BK hatch 2016–2020
- BL sedan 2017–2020
Last updated
Common Problems on a Used Holden Astra
The most commonly reported problems on a used Holden Astra (BK hatch and BL sedan) are a failed crankcase ventilation (PCV) valve that causes a whistle and rough idle, creaking front suspension bushes, and piston damage from early ignition on the small turbo petrols.
For the Astra you're looking at, a Shufti Tailored check works from the car itself: its listing, kms, PPSR and recalls by VIN, your photos checked, and a repair cost and offer.
Failed PCV Valve and a Whistling Idle
The Astra's crankcase ventilation (PCV) valve is built into the plastic valve cover. When it fails, owners report a whistle, a rough idle and oil leaks, and the fix is usually a whole new valve cover (ProductReview owner reviews).
Start the engine and listen near the top of it for a whistle or hiss at idle. The idle should be steady. Look for oil around the valve cover, and a check engine light.
Ask whether the valve cover has been replaced, with receipts. If it whistles, price the repair into your offer.
Creaking Front Suspension Bushes
On BK Astra hatches, the bushes in the front lower control arms can come apart inside, causing a creak from the front over speed humps. Holden's fix was to replace the arm (AustralianCar.Reviews).
On the drive, go slowly over speed humps and driveways with the windows down, and listen for creaks or knocks from the front. Check the steering feels tight.
Worn control arms are a moderate repair. Price it into your offer, and have them checked if the noise is loud or the steering feels loose.
Piston Damage From Early Ignition
Small turbo petrol engines like the Astra's can suffer early ignition at low revs under heavy load, which can crack pistons. Using the right oil and fuel lowers the risk.
Check the service history for oil changes on time with the oil Holden specified. On the drive, listen for knocking or pinging when accelerating hard at low revs, and watch for a check engine light or a misfire.
A damaged piston means major engine work. If the engine knocks, runs rough or has a check engine light, have a mechanic check it before you buy.
Which Holden Astra Years to Avoid?
No single Holden Astra year stands out as one to avoid. Newer ones usually have fewer kilometres and less wear. Whatever the year, a car's condition, service history and recalls tell you more than its build date, and Shufti looks up the reported faults and recalls for the exact car from its listing.
- BK hatch (2016–2020). 6 to 10 years old, typically about 80,000–130,000 km. ANCAP ratings: 5 stars (2015) for R+, RS and RS-V hatches built to 2019; 5 stars (2015) for Sportwagons; 5 stars (2015) for hatches built from January 2020. Stability control is standard. AEB is on some variants, and standard on Sportwagons and on hatches built from January 2020. Most have done enough kilometres for wear items to come due: check the service history for regular servicing, and whether tyres, brakes and the battery need replacing.
- BL sedan (2017–2020). 6 to 9 years old, typically about 80,000–110,000 km. ANCAP rating: 5 stars (2017). Stability control is standard; AEB wasn't available. Most have done enough kilometres for wear items to come due: check the service history for regular servicing, and whether tyres, brakes and the battery need replacing.
Kilometres are at the Australian average of about 12,600 km a year. Well above that means harder use; well below, ask why.
For the Astra you're looking at, a Shufti Tailored check works from the car itself: its listing, kms, PPSR and recalls by VIN, your photos checked, and a repair cost and offer.
Holden Astra General Inspection Guide
A guide to checking for Holden Astra problems, built on the used car buying checklist for any car. It can't cover every problem reported across its years in one viewing.
- BK hatch 2016–2020
- BL sedan 2017–2020
Tick it if it's fine. Cross it if it isn't, and note what you found so you can price it into your offer.
- Safety critical
- Affects how safely it drives or protects you in a crash. Best to have a mechanic check it before you buy.
- Negotiate
- Costs money to fix, from wear to major repairs. Get a quote and take it off the price.
01
Exterior
4 checks
01
Exterior
4 checks
02
Under the Bonnet
4 checks
02
Under the Bonnet
4 checks
03
Underbody and Wheels
4 checks, 2 safety critical
03
Underbody and Wheels
4 checks, 2 safety critical
04
Interior and Electrics
4 checks, 2 safety critical
04
Interior and Electrics
4 checks, 2 safety critical
05
Test Drive
5 checks, 1 safety critical
05
Test Drive
5 checks, 1 safety critical
06
Documentation
3 checks
06
Documentation
3 checks
Get this free inspection guide on your phone.
Work through the Holden Astra General inspection guide on your phone at the car. Capture images, audio and note what you find.
Scan to get the app
Rather have it on paper?
Stay Safe
Never go under a car held up only by a jack, and never open the radiator or coolant cap on a hot engine. Keep hands, hair and loose clothing clear of fans and belts when the engine is running, and do checks under the bonnet with it switched off where you can. On the test drive, hold a current licence, confirm the car is registered and insured, obey road rules, and only brake hard when the road behind is clear. Meet in a safe, public-facing place, take someone with you, and don't carry large amounts of cash to a viewing.
Disclaimer. Shufti is not affiliated with or endorsed by Holden or General Motors; Holden and Astra are trademarks of General Motors LLC. Figures are counts from Shufti's analysis of official records and published reports, not a statement that any particular vehicle is affected. This checklist is general information only and is not professional, mechanical, legal or financial advice. It covers common checks, not every possible fault, and a car can pass every item here and still have problems. It is not a substitute for a pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic, which is worth considering before you buy, especially if anything tagged Safety critical turns up. Repair costs vary widely; get your own quotes. Roadworthy, registration and transfer rules differ by state, so check with your state road authority. Private sales generally don't come with the consumer guarantees that apply when you buy from a dealer. You use this checklist at your own risk and, to the extent permitted by law, Shufti accepts no liability for any loss, damage or injury arising from its use.
What the General inspection guide can't tell you about the Astra you're looking at
3
common faults reported on Astras built since 2016
882
owner complaints on the related Chevrolet Cruze, 2016–2019
What's each fault worth?
Shufti's negotiation coach turns it into leverage.
Money owing, stolen or a write-off?
A tidy car can hide all three.
A Tailored check in the Shufti app covers all of that, plus:
- Guided checks for the exact car you're inspecting
- Crosschecks 3M+ recalls and owner complaints
- Spots issues from your photos and audio
- Test drive routes with turn-by-turn navigation
- Negotiation coach with repair cost estimates
- PPSR and government recall checks included
Get a Shufti Tailored check on your mobile.
Don't drive home in a lemon.
Not sure yet? Start free with the Holden Astra General inspection guide, and upgrade to a Tailored check for the car you're serious about.
Start from the listing
Drop in a link from any major car sales website. Shufti retrieves the important information about your vehicle to guide you through a customised buying process.
Start from the listing
Drop in a link from any major car sales website. Shufti retrieves the important information about your vehicle to guide you through a customised buying process.
* Shufti analysis, November 2026, of official recall notices, complaints lodged by vehicle owners with vehicle safety regulators, and independent reviews and owner forums. Faults are counted when two or more independent sources report them. See the recall notices for the Holden Astra on the government's Vehicle Recalls site, and how we check our facts.
Buying a Used Holden Astra: Questions Answered
Is a used Holden Astra reliable?
It depends more on the particular car than the badge: how it was driven, loaded and serviced. Work through the commonly reported problems above, read the service history for servicing done on time, and run a PPSR check.
Which Holden Astra years should I avoid?
No single Holden Astra year stands out as one to avoid. Newer ones usually have fewer kilometres and less wear. Whatever the year, a car's condition, service history and recalls tell you more than its build date, and Shufti looks up the reported faults and recalls for the exact car from its listing.
This checklist covers the BK hatch (2016–2020) and BL sedan (2017–2020) Holden Astra. Problems reported across them include a failed PCV valve, creaking front suspension bushes and piston damage from early ignition.
How many kilometres is too many for a used Holden Astra?
Kilometres matter less than how the car was driven and serviced. A high-kilometre car with a full service history can be a better buy than a low-kilometre one that's missed services or spent years on short trips. Check the history for regular oil changes, and find out whether any timing belt replacement is due, as it's a costly job.
Should I get a pre-purchase inspection on a used Holden Astra?
It's most worth it on a car where a hidden fault could be costly. Hidden crash repairs and gearbox problems are easy to miss on a short test drive, so check panel gaps and paint closely and drive it long enough to feel every gear change. Either way, start by checking the car yourself with this checklist, so you know what to look for and whether it's worth paying a mechanic to see. See Pre-purchase car inspection: what it checks and costs
How do I check a used Holden Astra for money owing or a write-off?
Run a PPSR check with the car's VIN on ppsr.gov.au. It shows whether there's finance owing and whether the car has been reported stolen or written off. Run it on the day you pay. See What a PPSR check covers and what it doesn't
How do I check recalls on a used Holden Astra?
Search the government's Vehicle Recalls site for the Holden Astra. Each notice says which models and build dates it covers and what the fault is. A recall on record doesn't tell you whether the work was done on a particular car, so ask the seller for proof, or ask a Holden dealer to check the VIN.
Mechanic, Checklist or Shufti?
Here's how Shufti stacks up against your other options.
A mechanic's inspection is the most thorough, but most buyers go without one. Shufti makes sure you're well informed either way.
| Feature | Shufti $24.99 per check | Mechanic Inspection $250–350+ per booking | General Inspection Guide Free in the app or on paper |
|---|---|---|---|
Guided, model-specific checks | Yes | Yes | No |
Crosschecks over 3 million recalls and owner complaints | Yes | No | No |
Smart detection of issues from your photos and audio | Yes | No | No |
Test drive route planning and navigation | Yes | No | No |
Instant report generation | Yes | No | No |
Negotiation copilot and repair cost estimates | Yes | No | No |
PPSR and government recall checks included | Yes | No | No |
Plain-English explanations, not jargon | Yes | Yes | Yes |
No booking or waiting required | Yes | No | Yes |
Not ready yet? Start with the free General inspection guide for your car's model.
Scan to get the app
Comparing Other Cars?
Looking at a different car? Use the used car buying checklist for any car or browse problems and checklists by model.