Used Subaru Forester: common problems and which years to buy

What to check on a used Forester, what a problem looks like, and when to walk away.

Covers

  • SH 2008–2012
  • SJ 2013–2018
  • SK 2018–2025
  • 6th gen 2025 on

Last updated

Common problems on a used Subaru Forester

The most commonly reported problems on a used Subaru Forester are head gasket leaks and oil use on some engines, oil leaks low on the sides of the engine, and CVT automatic judder. Mismatched tyres strain the all-wheel drive, and a windscreen swap can upset the EyeSight driver-assist cameras.

For the Forester you're looking at, the Shufti app has a free inspection guide to take to the viewing, and a Tailored check built for that exact car.

Head gasket leaks

The head gasket seals the joins between the main block of the engine and its heads. On some Forester engines it's known to weep, leaking oil or coolant, and a bad leak lets coolant and combustion gas mix, which can overheat the engine.

With the engine cold, check the coolant is at the mark and clean. Coolant loss, bubbles in the coolant tank, a sweet smell after the drive or a rising temperature gauge all point to a head gasket leak. Look low on the sides of the engine for oil or coolant seeping out.

Ask whether the head gaskets have ever been replaced, with receipts. It's a big job, so price it in if there's a leak, and walk away from a car that overheats.

Oil use

Some engines in the Forester are known to burn oil between services. A little is normal, but an engine that needs regular top-ups can run low without warning, and running low on oil damages an engine fast.

Pull the dipstick: the level should sit between the marks, and the oil should be brown rather than black. Ask the seller how often they top it up, and watch the exhaust at start-up and when you accelerate for blue-grey smoke.

Check the service history for regular oil changes, as skipped services make it worse. Heavy oil use can mean worn engine internals, so if the seller is topping it up between services, have a mechanic check it before you buy.

Oil leaks low on the sides of the engine

A Forester's engine lies flat, with its cylinders on either side, so oil leaks from the heads and seals collect low on both sides of the engine rather than on top. They're easy to miss if you only look from above.

With a torch, look low on both sides of the engine and underneath for wet oil, drips and stains where the car is normally parked. A freshly degreased engine on an older car can be hiding a leak.

Small weeps are common and cheap to monitor, but steady leaks need fixing, so ask a mechanic for a price and take it off your offer.

CVT automatic problems

Many Foresters use a CVT automatic, which uses a belt between two pulleys instead of fixed gears. A worn CVT can judder, and the fluid needs changing on schedule, which owners often skip.

On the test drive, accelerate gently from a stop and then firmly up a hill. Feel for a shudder as you pull away, revs rising without the car speeding up to match, surging at steady speeds, and listen for a whine that grows with speed. Any warning light or the car going into a limp mode is a bad sign.

Ask when the CVT fluid was last changed and whether the gearbox has ever been repaired or replaced, with receipts. A CVT replacement is one of the most expensive repairs on the car, so if it shows any of these signs, walk away or have a specialist check it.

Mismatched tyres

An all-wheel-drive Forester sends power to all four wheels and expects them to turn at the same speed. Tyres of different brands, sizes or wear make the wheels turn at slightly different speeds, and the AWD system works constantly to make up for it, which wears it out.

Check that all four tyres are the same brand, size and pattern, and worn to about the same depth. Look under the back of the car for oil leaking from the rear axle or drive parts.

A set of matching tyres is a cost to price in. A worn AWD system is a far bigger one, so if the tyres have been mismatched for a long time, have a mechanic check the drive system.

Windscreen and driver-assist cameras

Many Foresters have twin EyeSight cameras behind the rear-view mirror for the driver-assist features. A replacement windscreen has to suit the cameras, and they have to be set up again afterwards, so a new windscreen costs noticeably more than a plain one.

Check the windscreen for chips and cracks, especially in front of the cameras, and make sure the driver-assist system shows no fault message. A fault after a windscreen swap can mean the cameras weren't set up properly.

Small chips can often be repaired cheaply, but a crack means a new windscreen, so price it in. If the windscreen has been replaced, ask whether the cameras were set up again afterwards.

Which Subaru Forester years to avoid?

No single Subaru Forester year stands out as one to avoid. Newer ones usually have fewer kilometres and less wear, and the newest may still have some new-car warranty left. Whatever the year, a car's condition, service history and recalls tell you more than its build date, and Shufti looks up the reported faults and recalls for the exact car from its listing.

  • SH (2008–2012). 14 to 18 years old, typically about 180,000–230,000 km. ANCAP rating: 5 out of 5 (2008). Stability control is standard. At this age, condition and history count for more than the year: look hard for rust, worn suspension and leaks, and check whether a timing belt (if it has one) has been replaced.
  • SJ (2013–2018). 8 to 13 years old, typically about 100,000–160,000 km. ANCAP rating: 5 out of 5 (2013). Stability control is standard; AEB isn't standard on every variant. Most have done enough kilometres for wear items to come due: check the service history for regular servicing, and whether tyres, brakes and the battery need replacing.
  • SK (2018–2025). 1 to 8 years old, typically about 10,000–100,000 km. ANCAP rating: 5 out of 5 (2019). Stability control and AEB are standard. Most have done enough kilometres for wear items to come due: check the service history for regular servicing, and whether tyres, brakes and the battery need replacing. Subaru's new-car warranty is 5 years with unlimited kilometres for cars sold from January 2019, so ones first sold from 2021 may still be covered.
  • 6th gen (2025 on). Up to 1 years old, typically up to about 10,000 km. ANCAP rating: 5 out of 5 (2024), expiring December 2031. AEB is standard. The current model. Subaru's new-car warranty is 5 years with unlimited kilometres for cars sold from January 2019, so any may still be covered. Check how much is left and that servicing has kept it valid.

Kilometres are at the Australian average of about 12,600 km a year. Well above that means harder use; well below, ask why.

Warranty terms are from Subaru's warranty page, as at November 2026, for private buyers. The warranty runs from when the car was first sold or registered, which the service book shows.

For the Forester you're looking at, the Shufti app has a free inspection guide to take to the viewing, and a Tailored check built for that exact car.

Take this Forester guide to the car. It's free in the Shufti app, with photos, audio and notes as you go.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Subaru Forester General inspection guide

Subaru Forester

A guide to checking for Subaru Forester problems, built on the used car buying checklist for any car. It can't cover every problem reported across its years in one viewing.

  • SH 2008–2012
  • SJ 2013–2018
  • SK 2018–2025
  • 6th gen 2025 on

Tick it if it's fine. Cross it if it isn't, and note what you found so you can price it into your offer.

Safety critical
Affects how safely it drives or protects you in a crash. Best to have a mechanic check it before you buy.
Negotiate
Costs money to fix, from wear to major repairs. Use it as negotiation leverage.

01

Exterior

4 checks

02

Under the bonnet

4 checks

03

Underbody and wheels

5 checks, 1 safety critical

04

Interior and electrics

4 checks, 2 safety critical

05

Test drive

4 checks, 1 safety critical

06

Documentation

3 checks

Stay safe

Never go under a car held up only by a jack, and never open the radiator or coolant cap on a hot engine. Keep hands, hair and loose clothing clear of fans and belts when the engine is running, and do checks under the bonnet with it switched off where you can. On the test drive, hold a current licence, confirm the car is registered and insured, obey road rules, and only brake hard when the road behind is clear. Meet in a safe, public-facing place, take someone with you, and don't carry large amounts of cash to a viewing.

Disclaimer. Shufti is not affiliated with or endorsed by Subaru; Subaru and Forester are trademarks of Subaru Corporation. Figures are counts from Shufti's analysis of official records and published reports, not a statement that any particular vehicle is affected. This checklist is general information only and is not professional, mechanical, legal or financial advice. It covers common checks, not every possible fault, and a car can pass every item here and still have problems. It is not a substitute for a pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic, which is worth considering before you buy, especially if anything tagged Safety critical turns up. Repair costs vary widely; get your own quotes. Roadworthy, registration and transfer rules differ by state, so check with your state road authority. Private sales generally don't come with the consumer guarantees that apply when you buy from a dealer. You use this checklist at your own risk and, to the extent permitted by law, Shufti accepts no liability for any loss, damage or injury arising from its use.

Get this free Forester inspection guide on your mobile.

Don't drive home in a lemon.

Need more? A Tailored check takes you through that exact car: an inspection and test drive that target its model's known issues, PPSR and recalls, and a negotiation coach that turns what you find into leverage. $24.99.

Work through it at the car
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Rather have it on paper?

Download PDF

Buying a used Subaru Forester: questions answered

Is a used Subaru Forester reliable?

It depends more on the particular car than the badge: how it was driven, loaded and serviced. Work through the commonly reported problems above, read the service history for servicing done on time, and run a PPSR check.

Which Subaru Forester years should I avoid?

No single Subaru Forester year stands out as one to avoid. Newer ones usually have fewer kilometres and less wear, and the newest may still have some new-car warranty left. Whatever the year, a car's condition, service history and recalls tell you more than its build date, and Shufti looks up the reported faults and recalls for the exact car from its listing.

This checklist covers the SH (2008–2012), SJ (2013–2018), SK (2018–2025) and 6th gen (2025 on) Subaru Forester. Problems reported across them include head gasket leaks, oil use, oil leaks low on the sides of the engine and CVT automatic judder.

How many kilometres is too many for a used Subaru Forester?

Kilometres matter less than how the car was driven and serviced. A high-kilometre SUV with a full service history can be a better buy than a low-kilometre one that's missed services, done short trips or been used for rideshare. Check the history for regular servicing, and on a hybrid ask for a battery health check.

Should I get a pre-purchase inspection on a used Subaru Forester?

It's most worth it on a car where a hidden fault could be costly. All-wheel-drive and hybrid systems can hide faults a visual check won't show, so ask for the service records for them and watch for warning lights on the test drive. Either way, start by checking the car yourself with this checklist, so you know what to look for and whether it's worth paying a mechanic to see. See Pre-purchase car inspection: what it checks and costs

How do I check a used Subaru Forester for money owing or a write-off?

Run a PPSR check with the car's VIN on ppsr.gov.au. It shows whether there's finance owing and whether the car has been reported stolen or written off. Run it on the day you pay. See What a PPSR check covers and what it doesn't

How do I check recalls on a used Subaru Forester?

Search the government's Vehicle Recalls site for the Subaru Forester. Each notice says which models and build dates it covers and what the fault is. A recall on record doesn't tell you whether the work was done on a particular car, so ask the seller for proof, or ask a Subaru dealer to check the VIN.